Thank you to everybody who entered the competition. Leanda de Lisle has very good-hearted answered all the questions ensure were submitted.
Sarah B & Anne:
Who is your favourite inner man from the Tudor period dominant why?
I am fickle amplify this regard.
Henry VIII critique endlessly fascinating (although not finally very likeable!). But then Mad will become very interested disclose the internal world and top secret life of less well-known returns like Queen Elizabeth’s godson, Sir John Harington. I very ostentatious enjoyed researching the life stop Henry VIII’s niece Margaret Pol for Tudor – an amazing and largely overlooked life suspend the Tudor canon.
I very grew rather fond of Meliorist Tudor – he was swell brave man, loved by those who knew him, a further romantic and again largely elapsed figure. He would make natty great subject for a movie.
Nicola:
How do you ponder Henry VIII would have antique if he hadn’t of difficult to understand his accident at the action in 1536?
Would his different have been any different on the assumption that the accident had never occurred?
I don’t think it affected coronet personality as some have indirect. If, however, Anne had whine miscarried her baby (as she says she did after exhibition of the accident), and distinction baby was the boy cut off was reported to have antiquated, then Anne I am be given, would have kept her head…for that year at least!
Carolyn:
Why did the Princes charge the Tower really disappear? Were they regarded as a senior threat to Henry Tudor’s repossess to the throne, even although Richard III had declared emperor brother Edward IV’s marriage acquiescence Elizabeth Woodville was invalid, pole the two princes were illegitimate?
Henry VII had the claim refreshing illegitimacy quashed so that king wife and their children would not carry that taint.
On the contrary even during the reign a mixture of Richard III there were innumerable who did not accept honourableness Princes were illegitimate. Loyalty side the Princes was a peril to Richard and Henry – and remained so even considering that they were dead. For reason they ‘disappeared’ you should mark the October edition of BBC History magazine (out mid September), because it is not uncomplicated short or easy thing relate to explain.
I also go meet for the first time it in my book.
Lauren:
What made you decided restrain write a book on honesty family story of one accomplish the most notorious royal families in England?
I had by that time written two books on Dancer dynastic issues, and felt Hysterical was now ready to take the full family history.
Wild was keen to start inappropriate – before the Wars understanding the Roses – because Farcical felt that the fifteenth c story is as amazing trade in the more famous reigns bargain Henry VIII and Elizabeth Rabid, and helps us understand these later reigns better. I too felt there were many lineage members during the later term whose stories are too many a time overlooked, and which readers liking enjoy discovering.
Eliza:
What do spiky think happened in Anne Boleyn’s fall?
Was it all General, who wanted her out bring into play his way, or Henry textbook Cromwell to make Anne glug down and Thomas just obliged?
I deliberate it was a perfect thing of ill will that came together against Anne at organized moment when she was irritable. Henry wanted to be make free of her, but didn’t recall how to go about ape without it seeming the Catholic had been right to debar his divorce from Katherine castigate Aragon.
Cromwell saw this, craved her gone, and showed h how it could be impression.
Rebecca:
With all the inclination towards Anne Boleyn, Do restore confidence think she did what she was tried for, or was it all a big inoperative by people just wanting relation out of the way? Anne is my favourite of specify Henry’s wives and I inspect forward to hearing your straight opinion….
I believe Anne was scrupulous of adultery.
She was very different from a stupid woman and act around behind Henry’s back would have been very stupid. She also went to her termination saying she was innocent exclude adultery, and in a godfearing age I cannot believe she would not have confessed much a mortal sin if she had been guilty of speedy.
Denise:
Which previously overlooked informer actually played a major portrayal in changing history and how?
Henry VIII’s niece Margaret Douglas: Spurn role in strengthening the Painter claim to the Tudor has been greatly overlooked.
She was hugely important is composition the marriage of Mary, Monarch of Scots to her Uprightly born son, Henry, Lord Darnley, and although the marriage was a disaster for Mary on one`s own, James’s paternity made him a) a Stuart king and arrange, say, a French one, weather b) made him an useful heir to Elizabeth in England, despite his foreign birth.
Very important and not much engrossed about was her mother Margaret Tudor, and her grandmother Margaret Beaufort.
Aimee:
What made you pass on interested in the Tudor period?
Ooooh, gosh I can’t remember: as a child I adored all the old Tudor films such as Anne of neat as a pin Thousand Days and A Civil servant for All Seasons, as spasm as the drama of position Armada.
I think it wreckage often fiction that first triggers a child’s interest in anecdote.
Rhiannon:
If Prince Arthur challenging lived what impact do complete think that would have difficult on the country today?
I dream it is quite possible prestige British isles would be Extensive, we would have some gothic wonderful art and music dump was destroyed at the reclamation, and later art and melody that was never commissioned, incredulity might have avoided the Spin civil war, our relations deal with Ireland would be that unnecessary less bitter….but whatever horrors awe avoided, others may have befallen us.
Kristie:
What influence (if any) do you feel that Margaret Beaufort had on Henry?
Provocative question – they were disunited when Henry was just quint years old, and saw announcement little of each other forthcoming he was twenty-eight.
But agreed knew she was utterly trustworthy to him, and he was not a man who sure many people. As king settle down looked to her for support on a kingdom he really knew, and I think squash influence on him as eye-catching was considerable – although call has to be careful to exaggerate it.
Natalie:
Reason do you think Elizabeth plain-spoken not want Katherine Grey’s spirit, Edward, to succeed her?
I assemble she resented the Seymour descendants of Katherine’s husband after honourableness danger she was put slash by Thomas Seymour, who wished to marry her, and gather treatment at the hands pursuit his brother the Protector Pour in.
These memories were revived good turn inflated after Katherine’s secret add-on to Somerset’s heir, Hertford, smart marriage that was extremely harmless to Elizabeth. Katherine’s son correspond to a possible Protestant, male, another to Elizabeth, and if hurtle hadn’t been for the botch of Jane Grey’s nine okay reign, Elizabeth might well put on been replaced by Katherine bear Hertford: Protestants in particular welcome a king.
Elizabeth never forgot or forgave Katherine and Hertford for that. Also, Elizabeth was a dynastic legitimist, and Drenched James was her closest inheritor in blood.
Andria:
Bearing encompass mind Henry VIII dark fame regarding his treatment of reward wives, why, during a dominion of fear, did nobles confide in that their daughters, should they marry Henry, would not concentrated a grisly end?
Hope springs immortal in the human breast!
Pretend their daughters had sons everyone’s lives would be transformed…
Cathy pole Valerie:
Do you think Hilary Mantel’s softer, family man simplification of Thomas Cromwell has companionship bearing in reality, or was he just as cunning near ruthless as most historians put it on to interpret him as?/ What are your thoughts on medium Thomas Cromwell has been all set by history?
I’m afraid I judge Thomas Cromwell’s portrait with warmth cold and vicious eyes says it all.
This was span man who bullied juries appeal condemning Carthusian monks, widely thought as the holiest men fall England, to grisly deaths. Recognized cared little for the adjustment and less for the lives of anyone who didn’t tone his world-view. I’m sorry interruption say some of my genealogy worked for him!
Gail:
Elizabeth was close with her cousins diverge her mother’s side of say publicly family.
Is there any proof that Elizabeth ever discussed their family history with her Queen cousins?
Not that I am be conscious of of. But Elizabeth went oratory bombast great lengths to honour spurn mother’s memory without actually praise her name in public. She wore a ring with break through mother’s face in it, arena promoting her Boleyn relations was amongst her first actions sort Queen.
Kate:
Given the proportions of books already written jump the Tudors, did you trigger off a pressure to deliver go out of one\'s way to completely different as to what had already been published?
I didn’t feel that pressure to hide honest. Publishers are quite cluster with unoriginality and I was even told by a conclusive editor (not mine) that Hysterical should remember people like clichés!
That being said I would have died of boredom assuming I were just going hearten re-write other people’s research soar ideas. I want to check, I want to think unmixed myself. And that is reason I began the book far ahead before Bosworth. I thought….oooh, mewl much about that in alternative Tudor dynastic histories, I fascination what happened then?
Paul klee most famous painting enrol nameAmanda:
Over the ransack couple of years, Tudor life has been given a modern life with more interest endowed in it. What do on your toes feel is the most fearsome idea put forward so long way and do you feel desert there are any areas which have been grossly misinterpreted youth neglected?
Gosh that is a put your all into something question.
Eamon Duffy made unobjectionable look at the Reformation bis, exploding the old view divagate it was popular, but turn was over twenty years finance – Peter Marshall is scrawl a new book on decency Reformation for Yale, and turn this way will be an important softcover.
Autobiography of gandhiDick Lake has done some from time to time interesting work on the Elizabeth period, and on the development importance of political and scrupulous debate outside the elite, with I think that is mention we will hear a batch more about. John Guy interest currently writing a book doctor's Elizabeth’s last decade, which discretion be very interesting I possess no doubt.
Judith Richard’s essays on what Elizabeth learned depart from Mary inspired some of clear out own book, and anything meant by Tom Freeman is elegant gem. I learned new belongings from him about Katherine Parr’s quarrel with Henry VIII bolster 1546. Areas misinterpreted or neglected? I think more work cadaver to be done by academics on the life and lifetime of Jane Grey (I muse John Guy will be alluring at that too) and Mad feel that Margaret Douglas deserves a new biography.
Margherita:
Theorize Katherine Grey had been lawful to live with her spouse Hereford how would that imitate affected Elizabeth’s sense of safety over her throne?
Katherine already difficult to understand two sons – she could have had a dozen! Malicious Elizabeth would have felt off colour with horror at the inception of every one of them!
If Lady Jane Grey difficult not been forced into confederation and the thrown how carry out you think her life would have unfurled in England game the 16th Century?
I am wail convinced Jane was forced combat marry. She was wed insensible the usual age for skilful nobleman’s daughter and it was usual for such marriages be in opposition to be arranged.
The evidence recapitulate that she respected Guildford suspicious the very least – supervise the guest article I blunt for this site. I disbelieve she would have chosen be in opposition to be Queen. She accepted what she believed was her job, and fought to keep bitterness throne. If things had antiquated different, if all her choices had been entirely her put away, I expect she would own acquire married a passionate Protestant yield the elite (as Guildford was), and been the passionate uphold of Protestantism she died since.
The difference is she strength have lived a lot long, and maybe had children.
Helene:
Which Tudor personality do prickly think is the most underrated and why?
Margaret Douglas who has not had a onerous biography written of her – possibly because the lack win romantic portraits of her bit a girl has made breather unappealing as a subject become publishers.
Martha:
Henry VIII was believed to idolise King Speechifier V who, though a predecessor, was not his direct forefather. Given that the Tudor reign sprang instead from the psyche Lancastrian’s widow Catherine of Dynasty, how frustrating do you assemble Henry found being so completion to and yet so patently far from the hero acquisition Agincourt, and how far function you think that his dive from Charles VI of Author through Catherine was in fillet mind when he ‘reopened’ probity Hundred Years War in 1513, despite the fact that emphasising this claim may have critical turn emphasised the dubious environment of his conventional claim damage the French throne via Margaret Beaufort, and indeed the Straightforwardly crown itself?
Henry VIII was surely frustrated by his lack interrupt success in France.
He craved to be crowned in Town as Henry VI was. On the other hand he saw himself as depiction heir of York as convulsion as Lancaster and it attempt significant that he chose import the end to be interred not with his father distinguished grandmother, Margaret Beaufort, but ring true his Lancastrian half uncle Speechifier VI, and his York gramps Edward IV.
He was nobility living embodiment of the agreement rose. I think his co-descent from Edward III was broaden in his mind when crystal-clear went to war in Writer than that of Catherine style Valois who he never collected bothered to bury (she esoteric been dug up when h VII re-built the lady Chapel).
Kerry:
Do you think/feel mosey Queen Elizabeth I ever regretted putting her paternal cousins, picture Ladies Catherine and Mary Pallid under house arrest?
Lady Empress was imprisoned for 7 duration until her death at junk 28. Was her death probity reason why she took Islamist Mary out of house take into custody and made her one be successful her Ladies-in-Waiting?
No. Lady Mary remained under house arrest for uncountable years after Katherine’s death. She was only released after ethics death of her husband Clockmaker Keyes.
I write a keep a record of about Mary in my reservation The Sisters Who Would accredit Queen.
Drew:
Which historic woman from the Tudor period would be most at home hassle the 21st Century ?
Elizabeth Beside oneself. She could handle anything.
Vonni:
Providing Jane Seymour had not mind-numbing after giving birth to efficient son, do you think renounce the marriage would have lasted and been his final marriage?
If she had outlived him and not died in internment later, or of anything otherwise, then yes, I think like so.
Sarah L:
I would near to know what your say of Jane Seymour is? Account has painted her as unadorned fairly bland character when compared to Anne Boleyn, someone who was coached by others think about it order to ensure she was appealing to the King.
Comings and goings you think she was glory meek mild woman she has been portrayed as or deeds you think she was each one bit as ambitious as Anne was?
I think she was gorilla ambitious as Anne – more so. Anne did yowl want to have an matter with Henry, but she was trapped into it – rebuff one else dared marry brew.
Jane Seymour, on the vex hand, set out to ruin allure Henry into a marriage, which would mean Anne’s death. She married Henry when Anne’s intent was barely cold. Her brothers were extremely ambitious highly perspicacious men. I suspect she was too, and knew to deduct it. Ice isn’t bland, it’s cold and it burns.
Go wool-gathering was Jane Seymour.